Is the SEC that good, that bad, or that deep?
I know it is nothing more than life in the SEC, another season of upsets, blowouts, and hard-fought games in the trenches. But this season seems to have a different tone to it. Take a quick look:
The West:
-We beat Miss St 3-2, lose to LSU 26-21, beat UT 14-12, lose to Vandy and Arkansas in close games.
-Ole Miss plays close all year, loses to Vandy, beats UF, loses to S Car, and loses a close one to Bama.
-Miss St loses to us 3-2, is able to score 24 on LSU in its loss at Tiger Stadium, beats Vandy then gets routed by UT 34-3.
-Bama blows out Arkansas and UGA but narrowly beats UK and Ole Miss.
-LSU beats us, handles Miss St, gets blown out by Florida and narrowly beats S Car.
-Arkansas gets man handled by Bama and plays UF close until the 4th quarter, beats us then loses to UK after UK comes back by scoring 14 unanswered in the 4th.
The East:
-Florida routs UT, loses a close game to Ole Miss, and was in a close game with Arkansas until the 4th quarter then blows out LSU.
-UGA narrowly beats S Car, gets blown out by Bama, man handles UT and beats Vandy.
-S Car narrowly loses to Vandy and Georgia, beats Ole Miss and UK then narrowly loses to LSU.
-Vandy wins in close games to S Car, Ole Miss & us and leads the SEC east then loses to Miss St and Georgia.
-UK nearly upsets Bama, loses to S Car, then has to come from behind to beat Arkansas.
-UT is blown out by Florida, narrowly loses to us, loses to UGA, then routs Miss St.
And those are only conference games, those don't include (to name a few) UT getting beat by lowly UCLA, La Tech and GA Tech beating Miss St, Arkansas' near losses to Western Illinois and La Monroe or Bama's quarrels with Tulane before beating them a week after man handling Clemson.
After seeing who has beat who and in what fashion it made me start thinking this weekend, is the SEC down this year or that good? And the conclusion I came to is neither and both; huh?. But rather the SEC is now that deep where no one is safe week to week. I know that is college football and reason 12546895632458 (to add to a commentor's list earlier this year) that this sport is arguably the best.
But the fact remains that when the power houses of the last decade are narrowly beating and losing to second tier SEC teams while blowing out fellow powerhouses all while the second tier programs are easily beating each other but are also silent giant killers and easily capable of pulling the upset, that your conference is deep in talent and thus with out argument the toughest in the nation. Regardless of who your team is (for our visitors) we should all be proud to be apart of this great conference because this is the only conference that gives you a full slate of good games every week, where every team had better bring their A game every week. You don't get USC - Wazzu, Illinois - Indiana, or an Iowa St - Baylor (no offense, Mr Chizik) game.
So while in the end it is the SEC and some of the results are year to year always close (LSU-AU, UGA-USC, UF-Ole Miss) there have been others. But again it is the SEC and therefore nothing should come as a surprse. But this year just has a different tone to it.....at least to me.
Damn I love College Football
War Damn Eagle
0 recs |
5 comments
|
Comments
I think the SEC is overrated THIS year...
But I agree that we are both overrated and deep…
You can’t criticize USC for losing to Stanford and Oregon St, and call them overrated, and then say that Ole Miss beating Florida and Arkansas beating Auburn is a testament to the SEC’s depth. Let’s call a spade a spade here.
I’m a firm believer that the best football in America is played in the SEC in general, however that is not the case this year. I am fine with the Big 12 taking that title this year, as long as everyone knows that the SEC is still a very solid #2. Also, the big 12 is no better this year with their experienced QB’s than the SEC was last year.
The facts are that 2/3 of SEC teams currently have different starting QB’s than they did last year. 1/2 of the teams that kept their starting QB’s (Ark, Bama) have new OC’s. And then there are some teams who have new OC’s AND new QB’s. No surprise then that 3/4 of the teams with multi year starters for QB’s (Bama, UGA, UF) are the SEC teams ranked in the top 10.
The other 9 teams in the conference are trying to improve with new offensive philosophies and signal callers. I think we’ve seen the impact of a lot of teams that are rough around the edges from these recent changes in the first half of the year. Now that some of these new coaches and players have grown up a little bit, I expect that maturity to been seen on the field. By the time bowl season rolls around the SEC will probably be back to it’s dominating form, however we will likely not have a national title team to brag on this year. I think Florida is our best shot here, but they’ve still got a rough ride.
Where did I critize USC??
Where did I critize USC for losing to Stanford and Oregon St?
Good point about the QBs? I hadn’t realized that but it makes perfect sense.
As for the Big 12 vs SEC. Not me I still say the SEC is the toughest. For these exact reasons….the depth. Do I think the top 3 or 4 teams in the Big 12 are better than the top 3 or 4 teams in the SEC this year? Yes, but do I think the bottom 3 or 4 teams in the Big 12 (Baylor, TAMU, Iowa St) are worse than the bottom 3 or 4 teams in the SEC, us included? Yes. So that is why I say the SEC is still the toughest.
I agree with you on UF, you are right they still do have a rough ride to get through UGA and S Car to even get to ATL. And this is the SEC. As for Bama. I am not sure I have said it here or not but I have to friends that Bama is a good team however they are an injury or two from 4 losses. And Cody appears to be out a couple of weeks as of now. So we will see. Not only that but they still have to play LSU and us. No I am not being naive, I am speaking of a arch rivalry game, throw the records out the window and play on nothing but emotion.
I don't think he was singling you out
But many fans call USC out when they lose to the Stanfords and Oregon States of the world, saying they’re overrated. But then these same fans will say that Ole Miss beating Florida is a testament to SEC parity.
War Damn Eagle!
by PowerOfDixieland on Oct 20, 2008 4:09 PM CDT up reply actions
i believe the term is "down year"
i think it’s pretty simple. only 3 SEC teams have legit QBs and the 3rd of those “legit” Qbs is John Parker Wilson, so that should tell you everything you need to know. sure defense wins championships and all that, but really i can’t see anyone outside of Florida being a real threat to win the BCS title this year.

by 













