What's The Best Coaching Job In America?
What is the best college football coaching job in America? That's the question we kicked around the office earlier this week. John Calipari's move from Memphis to Kentucky has spurred a lot of discussion lately about what jobs are best.
I decided to do a little research and come up with my own list of the top five programs in all of college football. The list is completely subjective, but I did do my homework. You may agree with all of them or none of them. You may have them in a different order. But regardless of how you feel, it's hard to argue with the success of these schools.
I took into account tradition, weather, recruiting base, facilities, conference and budget. I did not factor in the competency of those who the coaches work for - athletic directors, school presidents and boards of trustees. All of us know that can be a huge factor - right Tommy?
So here we go...
1. Florida - Like it or not, this SEC foe has everything going for them. Their facilities are unmatched across the country and with an annual athletic department budget of $83 million the Gators have the resources to keep them state-of-the-art. The 2009 Rivals 100 list of top recruits contained 19 players that hail from the state of Florida - more than any other state. Urban Meyer's staff signed five of those athletes. It's still hard to believe Florida didn't win its first conference title until 1991.
2. Texas - The Longhorns are one of the few schools that can pick its players rather than having to recruit them. Austin, Texas may be the best college town in America. The Texas tradition is among the top five. What is there not to like? With an annual budget of $101 million, Mack Brown has little trouble keeping up with the Joneses. The state of Texas placed 12 athletes in this year's Rivals 100 and the Longhorns signed six of them. It's hard to blame Will Muschamp for staying put in Austin.
3. Southern Cal - Did USC make Pete Carroll or was it the other way around? I think it's safe to say that it's a little of both. With no NFL franchise in Los Angeles, the Trojans are the toast of the town. The weather is great 12 months out of the year and California is only rivaled by Florida and Texas for the most high school talent. This year's Rival 100 has 11 players from California and USC signed eight of them.
4. Notre Dame - Sure this is not your grandfather's Notre Dame, but don't underestimate the Irish. With the largest subway alumni base in the country and a major network to carry its games, Notre Dame is still among the plum jobs in college football. There is no tradition short of the New York Yankees that rival the Irish. With no conference to share television rights and bowl money, Notre Dame takes a back seat to no one in terms of revenue. The state of Indiana had no players on the Rivals 100 list, but when you are Notre Dame this is not a problem.
5. LSU - This probably comes as a shock to some of you. When I started my research, the Bayou Bengals were not on my radar. But the more you research the program the more you realize that Baton Rouge has a lot going for it. For starters, Louisiana consistently turns outs a decent crop of high school recruits despite its relatively small size. Bordering Texas and a stones throw from Alabama, LSU regularly crosses the border for talent. Surprisingly, Louisiana had five players among the Rivals 100. The Tigers signed six on the list, including two from the state of Texas. With great tradition and an annual budget of $76 million, LSU has things rocking in Bayou Country.
There you have it - the top five coaching jobs in college football. How does Auburn compare? Not too shabby. Jordan-Hare Stadium recently underwent several upgrades in recent years, including a new locker room, weight room and construction of a state-of-the-art academic facility. Despite having only four players on the Rivals 100 list this year from Alabama, Auburn is blessed with its proximity to Georgia and Florida, regularly going out of state for blue chip athletes.
Do you agree or disagree with the top five? I'd love to hear your thoughts...
19 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I'd switch LSU and Notre Dame
ND might not even be in my top five as of this moment. They certainly can get back to elite status. USC was way off the list only ten years ago.
I’d have LSU higher because not only have they been an elite program recently, they’re the only act in town, so to speak. They have no intrastate rival to take Louisiana recruits. Imagine UGA if there were no Georgia Tech (or vice versa), Alabama if there were no Auburn (or vice versa), etc. Louisiana has no competition in their state for the glut of talent there. When you think about it, it’s actually pretty insane to think they sucked so bad for most of the late 80s-90s.
The artist formerly known as...
Mr Redbird @ Viva El Birdos
PowerOfDixieland @ Track Em Tigers, other SEC blogs
Hmmmm.....
I guess I agree. I tried veryhard to find better schools in a better order and rally can’t come up with anymore on this level. At first I knocked ND out, but they still seem to pul in top talent on down years.
Even a Broken Clock is Right Twice a Day
Michigan..Penn State..Ohio State..Oklahoma
I think any of those 4 would be ahead of LSU.
Pretty good list...
But I agree with Indy, there are probably a lot of schools who can make an argument for the 4 and 5 spot. I think LSU is a solid top 10 job though.
The one argument I’d have is about ND. Their admissions standards take them out of the top 5 and possibly out of the top 10 in my opinion. It doesn’t matter how much kids are drawn to the Irish if they can’t get academically eligible. The other 4 schools on your list don’t have that problem, and neither would schools 6-10 if you were to finish the list.
The Bammers...
are upset that you didn’t include them in the list, Jay. You’re such a homerish hack, or so they say. They even devoted a whole fanpost to the subject.
I bet if enough of us go over there and say hello that some of them start cursing and they have to delete the post, as usual, anytime they get riled up. I’ve already left two comments. Anyone care to join me?
by War Eagle Atlanta on Apr 4, 2009 8:09 PM CDT reply actions
Like always...
You are unable to post the facts. No one is upset that Bama isn’t in the top five. However, most find it laughable that LSU and ND would make it. Nice spin though.
Truth is
that everyone would like their school to be on the LIST. The LIST goes as the success goes. At one time Nebraska, Colorado and Miami would have been locks for the top 5. If you look at the scene as it sits today then the top 3 on this LIST are as strong as it gets.
Alabama is NOT on the LIST after one somewhat solid season. Be a contender each year and/or(mostly “and”) have won the NC in the last 3 years and then you are a lock for the top 5. If Bama has another sold (top 5) year and wins the NC in the next 2 years then YES they would/should be in the top 3.
Unfortunatly that won’t happen(sarcasm)….they won’t catch Florida. They will lose at least 2 each year….and lose to Auburn at the end of the year and get knocked down in the polls…….much like the Curry years.
Even a Broken Clock is Right Twice a Day
Comepletly subjective true, but..
- If ‘weather’ is a criteria, then you just eliminated the entire Big 10, the Big East (except Miami), the northern ACC, the northern PAC 10 and the Big 12 North. And Notre Dame.
- Tradition- LSU has about as much tradition as Ole Miss, which is still more than Florida.
- Facilities- I’m sure USC’s on-campus facilities are top-notch, but they don’t even play in their own stadium.
- Conference- Notre Dame = no conference, and there’s the USC PAC 10 thing
Maybe you should re-research or change your criteria and try again. (and you don’t have to include Alabama because I know you don’t want to.)
What am I wrong about?
I don’t necessarily disagree with your selections (except LSU), if it was just a straight up question. My point was that you ‘took into account’ certain factors and then seemed to ignore them.
My top 5 taking your factors into account:
1) Texas
2) Alabama
3) Oklahoma (replace with Tennessee if you don’t like OK weather)
4) Florida State
5) Georgia
Wow, did ever you stir the pot at RBR
Talk about hit a nerve.
I wonder how many posts there would have been if you’d have replaced LSU with Tennessee on that list?
BS
Do you agree or disagree with the top five? I’d love to hear your thoughts…
You don’t want to hear anyone’s thoughts.
Just curious, what are the basketball top 5?
Going from the ridiculous to the sublime, but that is the question that started this topic, right? Ok, I know it’s late in the discussion but after watching the tournament championship (congrats Tarheels!), here are the programs that come to mind (in no particular order):
Kentucky
UNC
Duke
Louisville
Indiana
Kansas
UCLA
On the cusp:
Michigan St.
UConn
Syracuse
Others???
Hello?? Anyone left reading this post???
I’m going to bed…
one change
using your criteria, I would replace ND w/ OK. I would consider this somewhat of a weighted average though….putting more emphasis on recent success.
1.) UF
2.) USC
3.)Texas
4.)OK
5.) LSU

by 













