1st and Five: Top SEC Single Season Coaching Failures this Decade
Okay, you asked for it, you got it. After linking the thread about the top 11 worst coaching stints in CFB last week, most of you homers still wanted to talk about the SEC and SINGLE seasons. Never one to not capitalize on a good opportunity, (nor a good crisis) I present to you my list of the worst five single-season coaching disasters in the Southeastern Conference this decade (and century). And because coming up with 10 might be nit-picking gnat sheet out of pepper, I present it in the1st and Five format, so it is easily and quickly digested by all. And to be clear, to have a coaching failure, there must have been some scintilla of expectations present. Otherwise, we get back to that whole does a tree falling in the woods alone make a sound conundrum.
5) Mike Shula, Alabama, 2006, 6-7: Not everybody thought that the Tide would 'be back' for long under Shula, Sports Illustrated covers the year before aside. Alabama wasn't even ranked in the pre-season top 25 AP poll, despite coming off an impressive 10-2 season in 2005 where the Tide went undefeated their first nine games before tanking the last two conference games against LSU and Auburn. But the Capstone had hope, and this was to be the sink or swim time for Shula--either continue the winning or continue on his journey somewhere else. Also at stake was to break the spell against Auburn for Shula's first win against the Tigers since his playing days. Didn't happen. He lost his last three regular season games and his proxy, Joe Kines, lost the bowl game. End of the line for Shula at Alabama, as his firing lead to the susequent biggest manhunt in US coaching history.
4) Nick Saban, Alabama, 2007, 7-6: Okay, I swear I won't load this list up with Alabama coaches, but you have to believe that the aforementioned largest manhunt in US coaching history would come with some expectations, right? You simply don't double-down on a coaching salary and not think that good things are going to happen. They sold out the spring game. How can you not get up for the regular season? Actually, Saban didn't start out that bad. He won the first three games and six out of the first eight. It was the dropping of the last four regular season games that turned the season sour, including getting Croomed by Miss State, losing to Auburn for a sixth finger and the devastating loss to Louisiana-Mundane. After handing Saban the keys to the Crimson Kool-Aid Kingdom, many Tide fans were thinking about calling a locksmith.
3) Tommy Tuberville, Auburn, 2008, 5-7: Okay, the universe is balanced again now that we throw an Auburn coach to the wolves. And don't think he doesn't deserve it. Tubs had been averaging almost nine and a half wins this decade and had been coming up short with a return trip to Atlanta by only a hair. Auburn was a pre-season top 10 and expectations were very high with new OC Tony Franklin's new Spread Eagle offense. After all, it seemed to work in the Chick Fil A Bowl, right? Never mind that an offense so radical had never worked at Auburn, and wouldn't work that season, either. Tubs threw Franklin under the bus and eventually got thrown under himself, by either Jacobs, Lowder, himself, or all of the above. Even after having his fingers severed by Alabama in the Iron Bowl, Tuberville could have weathered the storm, but never got the chance--again, by reasons still unclear. Perhaps the biggest disappointmnet of the whole season was under-estimating Auburn fans' ability and desire to regroup around their coach.
2) Urban Meyer, Florida, 2007, 9-4: It seems a little strange to have on this list a coach with two BCS crowns in the last three years, but you have to take a closer look at the mystery meat sandwiched in between those MNC slices of bread. After going 13-1 in 2006 to win it all, Florida started 2007 ranked #6, looking for the first repeat of a BCS championship. A mid-season streak of two losses in a row to Auburn and LSU, coupled with a rare loss to Georgia, ensured that the Gators would not only sit home from the big dance, but from the SEC championship as well. And all of this was compounded by the fact that they were playing with the best player in all the land--Tim Tebow. Expectations were astronomical, but Meyer tanked it, punctuated by the lackluster loss to Michigan in the Cap One Bowl. Judging on how he rebounded from this season though, it almost seems worth it.
1) Phil Fulmer, Tennessee, 2005, 5-6: Starting the pre-season ranked #3 and looking to have their first SEC title since 1998, Tennessee was also looking to be the first BCS crown repeat customer. The wheels came flying off Fulmer's Purina chuck wagon somewhere in the middle of the schedule and it wasn't too long before Vols fans were in open revolt. After a close loss to Florida early in the season, Fulmer and company bounced back with a gutsy overtime win in Baton Rouge. After another conference win, they proceeded to lose four in a row, including a beatdown in South Bend and a devastating loss to Vanderbilt for the first time in 23 years--in Neyland, no less. Fulmer kept his job, probably under the condition that this never happen again, again.
0 recs |
34 comments
|
Comments
Think you're wrong about Saban.
Any Bama fan that was “thinking about calling the locksmith” was an ignorant idiot. You’re not going to just rebound immediately. Saban did just fine that year. Sure there might have been a couple of things that could have happened differently, but it takes a while to change people’s attitudes in addition to teaching them a new system.
Yeah, he was basically trying to fit a square peg into a circle...
with trying to run his gameplan with Shula’s players. Not to mention that there was a four game stretch with 4 starters suspended due to the Textbook Thing. Now, we may not have beaten LSU and Auburn that year with those players, but we sure as hell would have beaten UL-Monroe and Miss St. So that’s a 4 game swing in the W/L column.
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success" - Coach Bryant
Uh, I'll take Mike DuBose
circa 2000, for the win. Defending SEC Champions with a #3 preseason ranking, lost the opener at UCLA and went tailspin from there. They lost to Southern Miss 21-0 and to Central Florida, got blown out by Mississippi State and shut out in the Iron Bowl to finish 3-8 and cost DuBose his job. Fulmer ’05 was bad. This was way worse in every way.
Will - Rocky Top Talk
Like I said...
I couldn’t make a whole list with nothing but Bammer coaches on it…
:-)
by War Eagle Atlanta on Jun 2, 2009 9:37 AM CDT up reply actions
come on man
you know you put Saban up there just to be a dick…
‘When you build a house and you make it hurricane-proof by putting certain kinds of windows in it, and use cement instead of stick construction and all that kind of stuff, you’re getting prepared for what? A hurricane that may or may never every come." ’We’re going to have 12 hurricanes next year, we know they’re coming.’
- Coach Nick Saban
He should be #1, IMO
Bump off Saban
I've got one foot on the platform, the other foot on the train
I'm going back to New Orleans, to wear that ball and chain
by jd is legend on Jun 2, 2009 10:34 AM CDT up reply actions
Technically the year 2000 falls in the 20th century.
A century does not begin until January first of 01. So Mike Dumbose can’t make the list.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 3, 2009 9:44 AM CDT up reply actions
But the title of the post is about this decade
Either the last ten years or the decade we’re currently in. Do you consider 1990 as in the 90s or the 80s?
I've got one foot on the platform, the other foot on the train
I'm going back to New Orleans, to wear that ball and chain
by jd is legend on Jun 3, 2009 10:11 AM CDT up reply actions
Technically 1990 falls in the decade of the 1980's, and 2000 falls in the 1990's.
The best way to explain it is by counting. When you start counting, you don’t actually start at 0, you start at 1. So 1-10 is one set of 10, 11-20 the next, and so on.
If the list had been worst coaching jobs of the last 10 years then Dumbose is probably at or near the top of the list.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 3, 2009 10:18 AM CDT up reply actions
But it is not my list, and I think that is probably why WEA didn't include him.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 3, 2009 10:19 AM CDT up reply actions
No...
I had put the memory of Dubose out of my head, just like most Tide fans have, so I forgot him.
But yea, the decade of the 90s started in 1990, just like this decade started in 2000 and ends this year. The millenium is a little different, though.
by War Eagle Atlanta on Jun 3, 2009 3:00 PM CDT up reply actions
You could make good argument for at least 3 SEC teams from 2008 to be on the list.
I think 4 teams started the year ranked in the top 10 and 6 in the top 25.
LSU preseason top 10. Highlight win was against Auburn (which didn’t turn out to be such a great win after all). But they did rebound nicely in their bowl game against Ga Tech.
UT preseason top 20. Lost to big time underdog UCLA to open the season and never looked back. This season cost Fulmer his job.
Auburn was already mentioned.
Georgia preseason #1 or 2 depending on the poll. Blown out by Florida and Bama (at home) in embarrassing fashion.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 2, 2009 10:27 AM CDT reply actions
They may not all make top 5
but if you went to 11 like the other list, I think they make the cut.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 2, 2009 10:28 AM CDT up reply actions
Concur...
LSU could have easily made this list for 2008. Crowton horribly mismanaged Lee last year, and the Co-DC’s were horrible.
Hopefully Crowton has his act together this year, we know the DC problem has been corrected.
What about
a special mention for LSU in 2007, who needed a re-write of MNC precedent in order to advance?Not to take away from your crystal football of that year, but I still can’t believe you lost your last regular season game to Arkansas and still made the show.
I still think that was a dividend being paid to the SEC for the slight against Auburn in 2004.
And I did consider Richt for last season as a strong candidate and had him 6th.
by War Eagle Atlanta on Jun 2, 2009 11:34 AM CDT up reply actions
Regarding LSU 2007
When you end a season with a crystal football, I don’t think in anyway you can consider that season a failure.
I know they had a lot of luck go there way that year, but 2007 was a year like no other. The year started with #5 Mich losing at home to App St and had at least 1 big upset every week.
Now 2008 LSU is a different story. Defending MNC, preseason top 10 (#8 I think), 2 blow out loses to UGa and Florida, and losing to Miss St and Arkansas to end the season. In their defense, the were replacing a lot of key positions, but no one saw 2008 falling like it did.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 2, 2009 12:00 PM CDT up reply actions
No kidding.
Ask the 2007 Giants how they felt about their regular season after they held the Lombardi trophy.
Ask the 2008 Cardinals how they felt about the regular season after they made it to the Super Bowl.
I don’t care if you have 2, 5 or 10 losses, when you win the big one, nothing else seems to matter.
Don't get on him too hard LSU Jonno...
he just hasn’t felt what winning the big one is like.
It wasn't a complete rewrite
Oklahoma got to play when the lost the Big 12 championship game. They didn’t capitalize, but they got to play. At least we won a game before the MNC, the SEC championship.
ehh
this list lacks a Zookish quality.
no way Shula or Saban deserve to be on this list over Dubose.
also
Tubs has my top spot for biggest FAIL of the decade by not only not living up to expectations but also turning Auburn from a national power into a punchline over night. i still got love for Tubs but damn…the season of Death will take a long time to get over.
by suicidewatch on Jun 2, 2009 10:52 AM CDT up reply actions
While I don't disagree
With Richt and 2008, he did still win 10 games. Now Donnan in 2000 was a coaching disaster. You know the team he’d waited 50 years to coach. The dawgs weren’t preseason #1 but we were in the top10. End up going 8-4 with an Aloha Bowl victory. Talk about tanking it.
ding ding ding!!
we have a winner!!
‘When you build a house and you make it hurricane-proof by putting certain kinds of windows in it, and use cement instead of stick construction and all that kind of stuff, you’re getting prepared for what? A hurricane that may or may never every come." ’We’re going to have 12 hurricanes next year, we know they’re coming.’
- Coach Nick Saban
I would also like to add...
Houston Nutt in 2007 – Had 3 NFL ready running backs and the top QB recruit from a couple of years earlier (who was supposed to be developed by then) and still only went 8-5.
Ditto on Dubose in 2000 and Miles in 2008
And also Sylvester Croom in 2004, 2005, 2006, and 2008. He came in as a “recruiter” and was supposed to establish his territory in MS by this point. He was given about three years too long, IMO.
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success" - Coach Bryant
It would have been hard for anybody to win at Miss St when Croom took over.
They were one of the worst teams in the country at that time. They had next to no talent and were coming off of probation (as an Alabama fan you should be able to empathize with that).
The expectations were not that high when he got there and in 4 seasons he had them in a bowl. It made no sense to me that they fired him after last season, even if it was a let down from the previous season.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 2, 2009 12:55 PM CDT up reply actions
Mentioning 2004 and 2005...
was more of a joke than anything. I don’t think that ANY coach should be judged based on their first year, Cheez-it included. You will hear me take a few friendly jabs at Chizik if things don’t work out as planned (it’s my Bammer duty), but I genuinely feel that it’s likeley one of the hardest jobs in the world to unbrainwash 70 to 80 19-22 year olds (accounting for Redshirt Freshmen to Seniors) and force them to play a style of ball they’ve never played before. Like I alluded to above, you can’t expect a coach with Coaching Philosophy A to go in and win a Conference Title with kids recruited and coached to play under Coaching Philosophy B, all in his first year (or even two). But by year three, you should have your recruiting trail established, and all your ducks in a row. Croom didn’t have that, and he very well should’ve by year 3. These are the expectations of even the lowest of programs.
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success" - Coach Bryant
Expectations in Starkville aren't as high...
But I’m curious if you think that Croom would have done a better job in Tuscaloosa than Shula did? I’m inclined myself to think he might have done a little bit better.
by War Eagle Atlanta on Jun 2, 2009 1:39 PM CDT up reply actions
Relatively better would not have been that hard to accomplish...
but I do think that he would have had better control of the team, and therefore probably would have made a little bit more of an impact…
"There's a lot of blood, sweat, and guts between dreams and success" - Coach Bryant
who knows...
i think he would have done about the same as Shula. Im not sure Croom really was all that great of a HC. He said the right things, got the fans excited but at the end of the day just didn’t have it.
‘When you build a house and you make it hurricane-proof by putting certain kinds of windows in it, and use cement instead of stick construction and all that kind of stuff, you’re getting prepared for what? A hurricane that may or may never every come." ’We’re going to have 12 hurricanes next year, we know they’re coming.’
- Coach Nick Saban
We are talking about Miss St though.
It is going to be hard for any coach to win there consistently. They are the Vandy of the SEC west (at least in football, and without the nerds).
I am not saying that Croom was the second coming of The Bear, but I don’t think you can judge his ability as a coach based on his time at Miss St.
by Jumpn_JackFlash on Jun 2, 2009 5:06 PM CDT up reply actions
How about Tuberville '03?
In many ways that team was more of a disappointment for me than the ’08 team. At least the ’08 team kept most games close, with less talent than Tuberville fielded in ’03.
LOL
so you put our coach in his first year on this list? A first year season shouldn’t be on this list, especially considering how he turned it around in his second year. But then again this is an Auburn website and your not supposed to be objective, but it still pretty funny to see a lame auburn insult.
Almost as lame
as Saban’s first season in Tuscaloosa, yes. $4 M bought you one more win than Shula did. Sure, he was setting the stage for bigger things to come, but isolated in the one-season prism we are viewing through for this thread, it was lame.
by War Eagle Atlanta on Jun 2, 2009 9:59 PM CDT up reply actions
My point
Is if your going to look at this in a one season prism, then you have to conisder that it was a first year. Then you have to consider what the team was that he had inherited. If you consider what he had on hand then you can’t give a first year effort this grade, Ron Zook had worse years than this. Sylvester Croom. AND HOW IN THE WORLD DO YOU JUSTIFY A LIST WITHOUT COACH O ON IT? I mean EVERY coach O season was worse than Saban 2007. Your just putting him on there because your an Auburn fan, not because it’s actually one of the worst.
blah that was long
by Wallacewade04 on Jun 2, 2009 10:09 PM CDT up reply actions

by 













