Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Sixers Vs. Celtics: Countdown To Game Seven

Russell Wilson Commits to Wisconsin. Now What, or No Sweat?


Russell-wilson-nc-state_medium

 Turns out his new uniform won't be far off from his old one

 

Former NC State QB Russell Wilson commmitted to play at Wisconsin yesterday after a much deliberated decision between continuing minor league baseball and playing for us. Okay, I'll admit it. I really wanted this kid. I know the fan base was torn about what sort of impact he would be able to make right away under Gus Malzahn's offense, but I think he had all the tools to make it work. But with only one year of eligibility left, the best he could be would be to serve as a virtual stop-gap at the QB position until some of the highly recruited underclassmen can be brought up. While many fans couldn't have cared less if he signed with us, I wanted him real bad, but still don't think we're any worse off than where we were. More on that later.

I know it seems apparently real common with Jerimiah Masoli at Ole Miss last year and with Wilson announcing on Monday, but college football's equivalent of a free-agent doesn't really happen that often. For these kids to transfer out and play immediately, they must already have earned their undergrad diploma, which face it, even I managed to accomplish in five fall seasons worth of schooling. Naturally, the only red-shirting I received was taking a light class load during three summer quarters, which is probably the non-athlete's equivalent, but I digress.

The sore loser Tiger fan might claim that Wilson's style wasn't suited for us anyway. If that's true then why was Auburn in the running in the first place? Admittedly, I had never heard of him until this spring in spite of the big numbers he ran up last year. I guess that shows what ACC football means to me, but after watching some highlights of what the guy could do, I did see a little more agility and speed at the position than I've seen on the Plains in a long time (other than you know who).

Auburn was more than the hottest name at the moment, we were a legitimate fit and I'm glad he considered us. In the end, I guess that Wisconsin proved to be a better one--either that (or what an Alabama fan might claim), that Auburn couldn't raise enough cash to out-bid Major League Baseball for his services. Regardless, we shouldn't look at it as a black-eye for the program. Unless he was also considering Bammer.

But if you're Barrett Trotter or Clint Mosely or even Kiehl Frazier, do you think you dodged a bullet or were you never worried about the competition? I'd say the latter for them, but even more important, what do the fans think? The consensus of opinion among us is that the program is sorely lacking in the QB position and that we're almost ready to just amortize the next season in order to bring along the next crop of Cam clones like Frazier and Zeke Pike. Uh, not so fast my friend.

Star-divide

Worrywarts read into the lack of naming a QB starter coming out of the spring as another sign that we've fallen off the cliff in talent there. Hey, we had the same thing last spring, with no starter named, but only a fool wouldn't believe that refusing to name Cam Newton the man after him completing just a few practices was anything other than a ploy to keep him off the rest of the conference's radar. With that being said, I still think that Barrett Trotter gave him a good run for his money (no pun intended) and is my prohibitive favorite for this season at the moment.

The point is that Auburn doesn't have to announce a starter yet. Why lock yourself in when you have the likes of Frazier coming in? Don't get me wrong. I put precious little stock in true freshman QBs waltzing into the SEC and having any level of success as rookies. Very few players even with years in a program can come in their inaugural year and light things up. I remember when Kodi Burns was a true freshman and playing. Many Auburn fans pinned all their hopes on him. The rawness of his inexperience soon showed the reality. Regardless, there is one thing that Frazier can accomplish immediately--to hone the competition between Trotter and Mosely to make the coach's decision a little easier.

After basically one year of Chris Todd at the helm full-time in 2009 and one year of Cam before dashing off to the NFL, Auburn fans are thirsting for more longevity in that most vital of positions. If it comes down to Trotter and Mosely, one of them will have the chance to play the position for a minimum of two years (three for Mosely) and that's really all you can ask for these days in this conference. Yes, we do have the young guns coming up. Both Frazier and Pike have even me excited, but we got the crystal football not the crystal ball. We're going to have to wait before we see how these guys turn out. We'll have to consult Acid Reign on this fact, but I can't remember the last time an Auburn QB with a year or more experience as the starter lost his job permanently. Something to think about.

Don't worry, Auburn fans, and believe me. Just because a highly touted QB like Wilson was courting us doesn't mean we are weak at the position. We're not. Trust in your coaches and the program. Maybe we're all victims of Cam's success last year and are doomed to forever hold him as the yardstick to which all future quarterbacks must be measured. I once heard a Bama fan call Newton a freak, and he was right. But he was also just a streak--gone too quick. Let's get over it and give these successors the props they need and deserve.

With our recruiting machines running 24/7, our next freak is either on the way or already on campus. And  I'm not ready to concede a damn thing to anyone next year. Auburn must be dethroned from atop the SEC and the nation. And if you're short-selling Auburn based on one position, I'll take some of that action. See ya in the fall!

Comment 32 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Track Em Tigers

Rising from the Ashes.

Nov 2011 by Acid Reign - 48 comments

Going Ugly Early, Often

Oct 2011 by War Eagle Atlanta - 64 comments

A Turn in the Road

Oct 2011 by War Eagle Atlanta - 62 comments

Comments

Display:

QB situation

I was one of those who was glad we did not get him. I just dont see the guy learning the offense in 2 months and more importantly gelling with the team. With these high speed offenses run today you really have to know your receivers and RB’s well. But on your other points in the article I agree. It will be really interesting to see how Auburn handles its QB situation for the next 3 years with the talent level we have at the moment. Development will be key. And Im glad to see someone else who is not giving up on this year yet. War Eagle to that. Auburn seems to always play better when were told we wont do well.

by redheadcheme on Jun 27, 2011 11:32 PM CDT reply actions  

This offense?

"Our method is simplistic=fast. It’s so simple, as far as, you look to the sideline and you see just “36” on the board, and that’s the play."

Don’t get me wrong, it worked. And hell, maybe it works. I just don’t understand when people say Wilson couldn’t pick up the Auburn offense in two to three months. Gene Chizik thought he could, Gus Malzahn thought he could, and Russell Wilson obviously thought it was feasible.

A dynamic playmaker is what makes the offense go, not complicated schemes.

Audemus jura nostra defendere

Every day we make it, we'll make it the best we can.

by animalcracker on Jun 28, 2011 2:24 PM CDT up reply actions  

Chris Todd recently said.....

that he didn’t think that Wilson could come in this late and learn everything he needed to learn about Malzahn’s offense. Seeing as how he ran the offense I would think he would have a better grasp of what time is needed to learn the offense. Cam referring to how the plays were called does not refer to the complexity of the playbook, the reads, etc…..

I don't troll so I reserve the right to berate trolls as I see fit.

Just so you know I won't forget.....LSU Jonno predicted we would finish 5th in the west in '11.

by Todd92 on Jun 28, 2011 3:34 PM CDT up reply actions  

I see what you're saying.

It does seem to me that the offense’s success is predicated on who handles the ball, instead of how the plays are drawn up.

The familiarity with the other players cannot be understated, though, and that is the biggest obstacle Wilson would’ve had to overcome. Auburn’s offense through the first six games of 2010 was just good enough to get the W, whereas it evolved into a well-oiled machine (excepting one half in November, of course) as the other players learned how Cam would distribute the ball.

Audemus jura nostra defendere

Every day we make it, we'll make it the best we can.

by animalcracker on Jun 28, 2011 3:46 PM CDT up reply actions  

I agree that the offense got off to a slow start compared to the finish.....

but that is part of my argument…..rather than the familiarity of Cam with the playmakers and vice-versa I could just as easily make the argument that it was as much Cam’s familiarity with the playbook that improved as the season progressed….although Malzahn himself admitted that he had to learn about Cam’s abilities as well as a play caller. Either way the only thing I see wrong with your argument is in fact the success that the offense had under Chris Todd….I mean take a slow kid with a noodle for an arm and still finish in the top 5 in total offense? So no I don’t think AU’s success on offense is predicated on what kind of athelete is at QB…..in fact I think that Malzahn is smart enough to gameplan his Offense around whatever limitations his QB has and still be very successful.

I don't troll so I reserve the right to berate trolls as I see fit.

Just so you know I won't forget.....LSU Jonno predicted we would finish 5th in the west in '11.

by Todd92 on Jun 28, 2011 7:34 PM CDT up reply actions  

How About This

Can you imagine how much SEC tape he would have to watch to catch up. He would be so unfamiliar with other teams and their defenses. At least the current qbs have an idea of the defenses they will face in the SEC. Just an idea

by redheadcheme on Jun 28, 2011 11:55 PM CDT up reply actions  

I get what you're saying

but I think that may be an oversimplification of everything that happens from the pre-snap read through the execution of the play. Sure the play calling may be simple but learning to run the offense efficiently and correctly would take time I would think. Not that I know any more about it than anybody else…

Auburn Tigers 2010 National Champions

by FlyAuburn13 on Jun 28, 2011 7:23 PM CDT up reply actions  

Good read WEA.

I didn"t want him unless he could play for more than one year. I like the ones we got. Besides a one and done QB does not guarantee success especially in the SEC. Masoli found out how tougher it was in the SEC compared to PAC 10. Ole Miss went 1-7 in SEC and 4-8 overall. We will be alright without him and as you said I trust our coaches.

by PineMtTiger on Jun 28, 2011 6:27 AM CDT reply actions  

I think Trotter is going to do just fine.

I think a solid argument can be made that it was Wilson, not Trotter et al. who was scared of the competition.

Wilson has zero competition at Wisconsin. His arrival there makes them the instant Big 10 favorite. His arrival on the plains may give Auburn an extra win, but what’s the difference between 9-3 and 8-4?

"I know the quarterback has a strong arm, but...I mean the ball's not gonna outrun ME" --PP7

by LSU Jonno on Jun 28, 2011 7:18 AM CDT reply actions  

I dunno...

1st place in the west??

Toomer's for Tuscaloosa

by War Eagle Atlanta on Jun 28, 2011 9:36 AM CDT up reply actions  

In 2011?

You’re dreaming.

Audemus jura nostra defendere

Every day we make it, we'll make it the best we can.

by animalcracker on Jun 28, 2011 2:25 PM CDT up reply actions  

True

but it’s not absurd to think that a game or two in the West could mean a one- or two-spot shift in the standings.

by AU Tiger on Jun 28, 2011 3:28 PM CDT up reply actions  

Great read! I remember my favorite Florida football team 2006.

Folks really underestimated Chris Leak that year and he had a pretty good backup qb newbie who saw some playing time. I trust the coaches and was ambivalent about Wilson. I have high hopes that this team is going to be better than expected. And watch freaking out for 2012.

by aubgrad on Jun 28, 2011 8:22 AM CDT reply actions  

Having another athlete on the team...

……wouldn’t have hurt. But, I think he’s a better fit at Wisconsin. They run a pretty standard pro-style offense, and he’d likely know the playbook a little better.

…..Gotta agree about Trotter. I thought he looked clearly better on A-Day. Yes, I realize that’s just one afternoon.

…..Last two Auburn quarterbacks who lost their jobs permanently after starting for more than a year were Charles Thomas and Charlie Trotman.

…..Thomas started half of 1979, and all of 1980. Didn’t hit it off with the Dye administration, and didn’t make it though 1981.

…..Trotman just got too beat up to throw the ball. We were running the ball, and his job was to get it to Cribbs, Andrews and Brooks. He got hit every play making the pitch, and Trotman wasn’t a big guy. Trotman’s situation should probably be looked at as injuries sidelining him midway through his senior year, not really a benching.

......Drowning in cool elixir.

by Acid Reign on Jun 28, 2011 8:27 AM CDT reply actions  

The reason Wilson went to Wisconsin

is the same reason Cam came to Auburn: It was the better opportunity for the player. You don’t have to look further than the five big uglies up front. I think Auburn’s offensive line will be fine. Heck, I don’t think offense will be much of a problem at all as long as a receiver or two steps up and we son’t have any devastating injuries at RB. But for the QB with only one season to get himself into the NFL, he has to go with which team looks best on paper. And on paper that team is the Badgers.
WAR EAGLE.

by AuburnAlum05 on Jun 28, 2011 8:32 AM CDT reply actions  

I think he was scared of the competition and comparison

He wanted to make a big splash. He can be a hero in Wisconsin, but (unless I’m crazy wrong), he’s no Cam Newton. His best possible season won’t compare to Cam’s last. Plus, I think he was worried that Auburn wouldn’t guarantee him a starting gig.

Not getting Wilson’s talents may cost Auburn a win or two this year (I have no idea), but it sends a strong message to guys like Trotter and Mosely about the program’s belief in teamwork.

by first and thom on Jun 28, 2011 9:33 AM CDT reply actions  

I don't about scared but ...

I do believe your right – he did not want to be constantly performing in Cam’s shadow especially with a new OL at Auburn. He steps in at Wisconsin with an offense similar to what he was used to at NC State and with an experienced line. It had to be the right move from his standpoint.

AubTigerman
"The reason you come to Auburn is because of Auburn people.This is a special place, from the coaches all the way to the fans" - Andrew McCain OT

by aubtigerman on Jun 28, 2011 9:56 AM CDT up reply actions  

Wilson

I wanted him, it would have been a much easier trip this season if he had come. I believe we can win it without him, but can we win it all? Probably, but it will be a hard slog.

by AU6 on Jun 28, 2011 12:18 PM CDT reply actions  

Happy with our current roster ...

I want men committed to being Auburn Tigers. IMO Mike Blakely’s (potential) eligibility would have a bigger impact. Looking forward to Running Back U taking charge of things.

by Hong Kong Tiger on Jun 28, 2011 12:19 PM CDT reply actions  

We are so stacked at QB....

I was all ‘Meh’ about Wilson. Not that he isn’t a great athlete and I do wish him the best with the Badgers. But, we have great guys! Guys who have had time with magical Gus. The O-line worries me much more than the QB position does. I’m keeping my fingers crossed for Trotter this year…..

by Tiger on the mountain on Jun 28, 2011 12:56 PM CDT reply actions  

I didn't think we needed him as you all know.....

and I believe that AU is just as well off, if not better off, without him. The kid is a hell of an athelete but we don’t need another one and done…..we need to develop the talent we have and prepare for the talent we’re bringing in. Good luck at Wisconson Russell Wilson….and I truly mean that.

I don't troll so I reserve the right to berate trolls as I see fit.

Just so you know I won't forget.....LSU Jonno predicted we would finish 5th in the west in '11.

by Todd92 on Jun 28, 2011 1:17 PM CDT reply actions  

He would have started the majority of the games next year. But I agree with the idea most folks here have that it is not much of a disappointment. I think even here, most everyone realizes AU is going to take a significant step back next year. Time to develop some QB’s and build some continuity/momentum for the future. But WEA, you had really never heard of this guy? I am not a stat head, and don’t follow other teams, nor do I read as many blogs due to the fact there is so much more going on, but that warranted a double take. No offense, just generally surprised.

"Be polite to everyone you meet, but be prepared to kill anyone"-tc16cav

by otisnixon'sparty on Jun 28, 2011 11:58 PM CDT reply actions  

If he were coming for two years - maybe

But we don’t really need him. Lets put the ones out there we got. Auburn will be ok.

by GreenvilleAUfan on Jun 29, 2011 7:32 AM CDT reply actions  

Trotter is really good...

He just has one major issue in my view. The kid can’t stay healthy. I sincerely doubt he’ll last a full season. For me, that’s where the trouble comes in at for Auburn. I’m not impressed with Moseley so far in the least bit. I think Trotter is really good, but I haven’t seen him go through a whole season healthy yet and that’s not even starting in one SEC game. If the kid is getting hurt against Tennessee State or at practice, how is he going to hold up against LSU, Arkansas, Alabama and Georgia? Personally, I think Auburn wanted Wilson to add depth to the team and I don’t think he would’ve started early in the season, though. He would’ve gotten his chance later in the season. I hate thinking that we’ll be wondering what might’ve been had Auburn gotten Wilson. I hope that’s not something we think about this season but I think it will happen at least a couple of times.

It's Auburn against the world. Good luck world.

by Sparkey on Jun 29, 2011 2:30 PM CDT reply actions  

Nah,

you can’t spend time wondering ‘what might have been’. Just put on the pads, get out there and play! (figuratively of course). I think that we are going to be great in the QB position…we can rehash midseason though.

by Tiger on the mountain on Jun 29, 2011 4:54 PM CDT up reply actions  

Sparkey did you not watch last season?

You know the one in which Trotter went through without an injury? Take a valium….it’ll be ok.

I don't troll so I reserve the right to berate trolls as I see fit.

Just so you know I won't forget.....LSU Jonno predicted we would finish 5th in the west in '11.

by Todd92 on Jun 30, 2011 10:13 AM CDT up reply actions  

Tiger on the Mountain will have to send me some...

No, he didn’t. He got pulled early last season against the Tennessee whatever it was that Auburn beat 52-3 or something like that. I’m not just being pessimistic.

It's Auburn against the world. Good luck world.

by Sparkey on Jul 4, 2011 5:38 PM CDT up reply actions  

Trotter tweaked his knee in the ULM game.....

and was ready to play the following week for the Kentucky game had he been needed. Sparkey college football is full of rebuilt knees especially in the offensive backfield…….if Trotter can’t last a season then Mosely will be ready to step in….but I have no reservations about Trotters ability to not only stay healthy but to lead the team. All the hand wringing is a bit premature…..Trotter is not as fragile as Caudle was. I’ll say it again…..had Chizik and Malzahn wanted Wilson they would have gone after him harder and probably told him it was his job to lose if he came…..since they didn’t get him I have to believe that they have faith in the talent that is here…….and if Malzahn can put up the kind of numbers that he did with Chris Todd at QB then what do you think he can do with Trotter or Mosely?

I don't troll so I reserve the right to berate trolls as I see fit.

Just so you know I won't forget.....LSU Jonno predicted we would finish 5th in the west in '11.

by Todd92 on Jul 6, 2011 11:40 AM CDT up reply actions  

Here's why I like you
and if Malzahn can put up the kind of numbers that he did with Chris Todd at QB then what do you think he can do with Trotter or Mosely?

I’ve believed this for so long, but thought maybe it was a little unfair (or unkind) to say.

I’ll be over here nodding vigorously, NOT worrying about the QB situation, while trying to cope with the ulcer that the thoughts of our secondary play gives me.

by AU Tiger on Jul 7, 2011 8:06 AM CDT up reply actions  

Damnit...

I’m not worried. I just know he won’t last a season. The kid is injury prone like it or not. I’m not hand wringing I’m judging what I’ve seen.

It's Auburn against the world. Good luck world.

by Sparkey on Jul 7, 2011 11:26 AM CDT up reply actions  

It wasn't his knee in the game I'm talking about Todd...

It was his head. He goes head first into defensive linemen. He does that against the mastodons that are in the SEC, he’ll go to concussion city. The valium thing was a joke, I’m out lol. I am not being scared here, our quarterback won’t be the focal point of the team as it was last season. Unfortunately, I think it’s a weakness, but Malzhan is certainly good enough to overcome said weakness.

It's Auburn against the world. Good luck world.

by Sparkey on Jul 7, 2011 11:29 AM CDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Auburn's Oldest and Most Read Independent Blog

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Tom_of_the_jungle_small
BIG CATS
_vc00396_small
Whose fanbase is more redneck? A research project
Sir_fidget_knight_of_the_roundtable_small
Coach Chizik on the SEC Coaches Teleconference
Sir_fidget_knight_of_the_roundtable_small
Auburn Hires New Basketball Coach
_vc00396_small
1000 Bammers will be returning vanity plates
Auburn_plane_small
Interesting Proposal for New SEC Format
_vc00396_small
Toomers Trees Show Signs of New Growth
Sir_fidget_knight_of_the_roundtable_small
NOLA Bound!
281860_252578001438827_240819579281336_913644_6795186_a_small
When it rains it pours if your last name is Tuberville

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Headshot_small Jay Coulter

Gg455b_small War Eagle Atlanta

Acid_reign_small Acid Reign

Img_8384-3_small aubtigerman

Koolbell_and_tootie_in_auburn_small KoolBell777